ARGUMENT ROOT
-
Abdullah Al Rajjak PRO 08:24 AM"The Quran was revealed after the Bible, serving as the final testament. Its textual integrity has been preserved through the Hafiz tradition (oral memorization) since the 7th century, unlike other scriptures which have undergone revisions."-
Jhon's Ahmed CON 08:26 AMChronological succession doesn't prove authenticity. We need historical verification of the written text (Uthmanic Codex) compared to pre-Uthmanic manuscripts like the Sana'a manuscript to verify status scientifically.-
Abdullah Al Rajjak PRO 08:30 AMAgreed on verification. The carbon dating of the Birmingham Quran manuscript places it within the lifetime of the Prophet.
-
Scholar Yusuf PRO 08:32 AMFurthermore, the minor dialectal variations (Qira'at) do not constitute a change in meaning, but rather enrich the understanding.
-
-
Fatima H PRO 08:28 AMThe oral tradition (Mutawatir) is far stronger than isolated written texts in preserving language nuance and pronunciation over centuries.-
Critic X CON 08:35 AMBut memory is fallible. How do we account for the variances recorded in early Hadith literature regarding recitation?
-
-
Abdullah (Pro)
Jhon's (Con)
PRO SUPPORT
CON SUPPORT
2,451
1,320
--- Debate Started 10 mins ago ---
User123: Carbon dating is key here.
LogicFan: What about the Sana'a text?
Muslim_Logic: Lower text was practice.
Mod_Bot: Please keep arguments civil.
Dave: Abdullah is calm, Jhon is aggressive.